迷你词

以文会友

拜登的标志是否提及中国的 “三红旗”?

| 暂无评论

阴谋往往是在旁观者的眼中。

【宣称】

2020 年民主党总统候选人乔·拜登的三条红色条纹是对中国社会主义政策的点头。

【结论】


【原文】

U.S. Election Day is Nov. 3, 2020. Check your state’s vote-by-mail options. Browse our coverage of candidates and the issues. And just keep fact-checking.

In October 2020, messages started to circulate on social media claiming that the three red stripes on Democratic presidential nominee Joe Biden’s logo were a reference to the so-called “three red banners” that outlined the socialist policies of Mao Zedong, the chairman of the Communist Party of China in the 1950s:

This is a genuine image of one of the logos the Biden-Harris ticket has used in their campaign as well as a genuine screenshot (to the right) from a Wikipedia page about the three red banners. However, the logic used to connect these two dots — Mao described a portion of his socialist policies as “three red banners,” therefore, items with three red stripes are about socialism — does not hold up under the lightest scrutiny.

For starters, “three red banners” is a reference to an ideological philosophy, not a specific visual design. In other words, China did not have a physical flag representing the three red banners in a similar fashion displayed on Biden’s logo. This claim is attempting to connect a textual description of a 1950s policy with a visual representation of the letter “E” in the campaign logo. 

Here’s how QZ described Mao’s “three red banners”:

The long history of China’s obsession with numbered policies starts with Mao.

The Three Red Banners—the “General Line for socialist construction,” the “Great Leap Forward” and the “people’s communes”—laid out how Mao’s socialist policies would transform China. But they are the de facto culprits of the Great Famine, Yang said.

The first banner is an ideological slogan that calls on Chinese people to build a socialist state. The Great Leap Forward, initiated by Mao in 1958, aims to transfer China into an industrialized country. And the people’s communes put households together in rural areas where they shared everything from food to farm tools — a way to discount individuality and centralize more manpower and resources for agricultural and industrial production.

The claim that Biden’s logo is a reference to the socialist policies of Mao in China during the 1950s is based solely on the fact that Biden’s logo contains three red lines. 

As the “three red banners” does not refer to any specific visual design, one could connect these socialist policies to any item adorned with three red stripes. By this logic, anybody living in Hawaii, Puerto Rico, Ohio, or working for the New York City Fire Department could be labeled a communist as these entities all use flags containing three red stripes. 

In addition to the logical flaws of this comparison, Mekanism, the ad agency that created Biden’s logo, has already explained what this logo is supposed to symbolize.

Aimee Brodbeck, the company’s designer and art director who led the team that created the logo, said that the stripes and the colors of the logo were nods to the American flag. More specifically, Brodbeck explained that the three stripes represent the three branches of the U.S. government. 

“The logo is approachable and strong, just like the Biden name. By incorporating nods to the American flag, the logo is a representation of Biden’s investment in America. The 3 stripes represent the branches of government and the strength of unity with Biden. The logo also nods to the familiarity of the Obama “O” logo where 3 stripes are seen.

Snopes.com
Since 1994
Help Supercharge Snopes For 2020

We have big plans. We need your help.

发表评论

*为必填字段!